Posted on Thursday, January 30th, 2020 at 5:13 am    

You are injured in a motorcycle accident that was not your fault. After receiving medical care and being out of work while you recover, you expect the insurance company for the at-fault driver to compensate you for your injuries and losses. However, you receive a letter from the insurance provider claiming that the value of your claim is one-half of the amount you believe you are entitled to receive. They refer to California’s comparative fault law as their reason for reducing the amount of your claim. Can they do that? What is comparative fault?

California’s Pure Comparative Fault Standard

Each state has enacted laws or has case law that defines the state’s standard for comparative fault or contributory negligence. The laws vary by state. Therefore, you should always discuss your case with an attorney before accepting anything an insurance company might tell you about comparative fault or contributory negligence.

California case law has established a pure comparative fault standard for use in cases involving negligence and injury. The theory behind comparative fault is that an individual’s compensation for an injury claim is based on the individual’s proportionate share of fault for the cause of the accident or injury. In other words, the more at-fault you are for the cause of the motorcycle accident, the less money you can receive for your damages.

Let’s assume that your motorcycle accident claim is worth $300,000. The insurance company claims that you are 50 percent at fault for the cause of the crash. Therefore, the amount of your compensation for the injury claim is reduced by 50 percent. The most you could receive in this case would be $150,000 (total value of the claim multiplied by 50 percent).

California’s pure comparative fault standard allows accident victims to recover compensation even if they are 99 percent responsible for the cause of the crash. Some states have a 50 percent or 51 percent bar for comparative fault claims. In those states, if the victim of an accident is more than 50 or 51 percent at fault (depending on the state), the victim is barred from receiving any compensation for the injury claim.

Blaming Bikers for Motorcycle Accidents

Some people believe that bikers are inherently reckless and dangerous. They assume all motorcyclists take too many chances when riding, always exceed safe speeds, and are reckless. Insurance companies often take advantage of these untrue, unfounded, and unfair stereotypes of motorcyclists to allege that a rider is responsible for the cause of a crash. In cases in which fault is difficult to prove, the insurance company may be successful in using this tactic with a jury.

Why would the insurance company use this tactic? Because they can reduce the amount they must pay to settle the claim under comparative fault standards. The more blame they can place on the biker for the cause of the motorcycle accident, the less money they must pay.

Contact a Sacramento Motorcycle Accident Attorney for Help

The Tiemann Law Firm Sacramento personal injury lawyers understand insurance tactics, including the use of comparative fault to reduce the value of a valid injury claim. We stand with motorcyclists and fight for full compensation for all damages. Let us help you hold a reckless and negligent driver responsible for the pain, suffering, and financial losses you incurred because of a motorcycle crash.

Contact The Tiemann Law Firm at (916) 999-9000 or by visiting our website to schedule a free consultation with one of our Sacramento motorcycle accident attorneys.

Client Testimonials

Hanna Padilla Testimonial

From the very start of my case the Tiemann Law Firm was wonderful. Perter came all the way to my home to sit down and talk to me about my options. He made me and my partner feel very comfortable and promised us he would take the very best care of my case. Peter kept me informed every step of the way and was always on top of things. everything was done in a timely manor and I always felt like I was the only case he was working on because he was so fast. In the end Peter got me back way more money than I ever expected. I would recommend this law firm to everyone. I am very happy with the outcome of my case thanks to the Tiemann Law Firm! Thank you!

Matt H. Testimonial

I was in a car accident a while back where I was injured and had to miss work for an extended period of time.  After nearly a year of fighting with the insurance company with no results and no progress, I met with Jelena Tiemann.  I couldn't have asked for a more responsive and supportive advocate.  We quickly reached a settlement and I finally was able to move from the stress and burden of feuding with my insurance.  I highly recommending meeting with Jelena if you're in need of a lawyer.

Star Fire Testimonial

It is hard to put into words the care and dedication that I received from the Tiemann’s. They have been here for me every step of the way and were always available when I had questions or concerns. My husband and I will be forever grateful for everything they have done for us and our family. Thank you so much for all of the hard work and time you have put into my case, we greatly appreciate it and your friendship. We highly recommend this firm and will always be thankful for everything they have done. Thank you so much again, Kim

Lendzey Garcia

I was in a very bad/ major car accident I originally had an attorney who wasn’t trying to help me out much or take any of my calls so I called Tiemann and told them my situation. They made it an AWESOME and Smooth transition over to them and took on both cases I had. I just settled on my big case and am beyond great full. For them and their team! I highly recommend them. To add on to this a little On how much they will work with you, I moved to Montana in the middle of all Of this and it was not an issue!

Maye Ly Testimonial

I just saw my lawyer Jelena Tiemann on a t.v ad, which reminded me how much she helped when I was in a desperate situation. I just love her! That is why I feel a need to tell everyone. I had a situation that happened & didn’t know what to do, our where to go. I didn’t even know if she could help me or if any lawyer could. All I wanted was it to go away & was afraid most lawyers wanted to drag it out & possibly go to court. For one she was very professional but was very personable (maybe b.c she’s a lady). She didn’t make me feel embarrassed or self-conscious that I did something wrong or was the cause of the situation. She immediately said we should try our best before going to court. Let me handle some paperwork, if at the last we do go to court we have documents. She gave me all the details, pros and cons but reassured me she deals with these cases all the time. She came through and made it as painless as possible. I now have my life back.